Merchants’ Square Cookie Plug –
Carmel’s Top Bakery & Dessert Shop
Bakery Hours for Cookies in Carmel
Monday: 12pm – 10pm
Tuesday: 12pm – 10pm
Wednesday: 12pm – 10pm
Thursday: 12pm – 10pm
Friday: 12pm – 10pm
Saturday: 12pm – 10pm
Sunday: 12pm – 10pm
Carmel’s top bakery & dessert shop, Cookie Plug, slangs fat, thick, ridiculously Phat cookies—part cake, part brownie, part cookie—that are straight-up redefining desserts in Carmel. Located in Merchants’ Square at 2442 E 116th St (right between Flix Brewhouse and the Monon Trail), our cookie shop brings that late-night, street-style vibe with delivery, pickup, catering, stuffed cookies, cookie ice-cream sandwiches, keto options, custom cookie cakes, and more! 🍪🔥
Why People Love Our Cookies in Carmel
Jaisalyn Wilson
Amazing cookies and a great atmosphere 10/10 would recommend
Sydney Roule
Must Try! Loved the cookies and the drink. Especially happy they have a keto option. Fun experience with the DJ on the first day!
fishybeastmode
Great job with a great grand opening! My son and I were so excited to be there and try things out. You all killed it! We will definitely be back very soon!
CONNECT WITH US