black order delivery and pickup now button
Get Directions
Call Store

Madisonville  Cookie Plug –
Cincinnati’s Top Bakery & Dessert Shop

madisonville cookie plug cookie bakery in cincinnati oh cookies for delivery
Digitally drawn cookies on a carryout food bag
Carryout
cookie plug bakery loyalty rewards program white
Rewards
Digitally drawn white delivery truck with a cookie on it
Delivery
Digitally drawn dishes with pictures of large cookies with bites taken out of them
catering
Digitally drawn cookies on a carryout food bag
Carryout
Digitally drawn white delivery truck with a cookie on it
Delivery
cookie plug bakery loyalty rewards program white
Rewards
Digitally drawn dishes with pictures of large cookies with bites taken out of them
catering
Brick storefront with a large black and white graffiti mural with Biggie, sitting on speakers with cookies all around him.

Bakery Hours for Cookies in Cincinnati:

Monday: 10 am – 8 pm
Tuesday: 10 am – 8 pm
Wednesday: 10 am – 8 pm
Thursday: 10 am – 8 pm
Friday: 10 am – 8 pm
Saturday: 10 am – 8 pm
Sunday: Closed

Cincinnati’s top bakery & dessert shop, Cookie Plug, slangs fat, thick cookies—part cake, part brownie, part cookie—that redefine desserts in Cincinnati. Find us right next to Cali Pro Nail Salon and Ali Baba Mediterranean Grill Cincinnati. Our cookie shop vibe offers delivery, pickup, cookie ice cream sandwiches, keto cookies, custom cookie cakes, and more!

Why People Love Our Cookies in Cincinnati

Check out our reviews here!

Blue circle with a white C with five golden stars

Corey McDonald

🔥 I recently had the pleasure of taking my family to the Cincinnati Cookie Plug location. The cookies speak for themselves. Crispy on the outside and moist and chewy on the inside(not raw dough) The options seemed endless. But,seeing how we drove from Columbus for the family to try,couldn’t try them all at once.I had to have another reason to go back 😁

Hot pink circle with a white D with five golden stars

Dean Bogner

Recently found this place, did not know it exists and we are right up the street. Read the reviews and had to try for ourselves. These cookies are delish, especially if you like cookie dough. We did read the instructions and put in the microwave for 10 seconds to experience a much softer, more “gooey” cookie. We purchased 4 large cookies, 4 “keto” cookies, and some of the “Dog cookies”.

Mint green circle with a white M with five golden stars

Mark Bryant Jr

This place is awesome. My wife and I went to one in San Antonio, TX and have been hooked ever since. I went and bought two boxes of cookies before the holidays at the Red bank location and they were amazing as always. Atmosphere and staff A+ too.

Image of Google Maps that marks the Madisonville Cincinnati Cookie Plug bakery in Cincinnati, OH

Get to the best cookies in Cincinnati from the Withrow University High School:

Follow these directions to get to our bakery:

  • Head southwest on Madison Rd for 0.2 mi.
  • Turn right onto Dana Ave in 0.5 mi.
  • In 0.3 mi, turn right to merge onto I-71 N toward Columbus.
  • Merge onto I-71 N in 3.3 mi.
  • Take exit 9 for Red Bank Rd toward Fairfax in 0.3 mi.
  • In 1.0 mi, continue onto Red Bank Expy.
  • Turn right onto Hetzel St in 180 ft.
  • Take a sharp right. Your destination will be on the left in 131 ft.

Craving cookies in Cincinnati? Browse our menu.

CONNECT WITH US