Evansville Cookie Plug –
Evansville’s Top Bakery & Dessert Shop
Bakery Hours for Cookies in Evansville:
Monday: 12pm – 9pm
Tuesday: 12pm – 9pm
Wednesday: 12pm – 9pm
Thursday: 12pm – 9pm
Friday: 12pm – 12am
Saturday: 12pm – 12am
Sunday: 12pm – 9pm
Evansville’s top bakery & dessert shop, Cookie Plug, slangs fat, thick cookies—part cake, part brownie, part cookie—that redefine desserts in Evansville. Find us down the street from Bud’s Rockin’ Country Bar & Grill and Lili Lu Designs. Our cookie shop vibe offers delivery, pickup, cookie ice cream sandwiches, custom cookie cakes, and more!
Why People Love Our Cookies in Evansville
COURTNEE LIPPS
I am so impressed with this place!! The staff was so kind, they actually let me try their special for FREE! The cookie was so so SO good! It wasn’t overly sweet and the presentation was nice! The atmosphere was very hip and eye catching. I’ll definitely be visiting this place again soon!
REAGEN RADDE
The vibes are here!! The little cookie shop is so cute and the staff was super nice & friendly to my 3 year old! The cookies are all very unique and we didn’t dislike any of the ones we tried. The cookies are huge so definitely worth the price.
KIM ALLEN
Not your typical cookie. Definitely unique. The centers are gooey and very rich. the s’more is good. I do also like the Pink Strawberry cheesecake. If you are looking for a chewy outside and gooey soft very rich and extra sweet treat then it is definitely a good choice.
Get to the best cookies in Evansville from Mesker Park Zoo:
- Head west toward Mesker Park Dr.
- Turn right toward Mesker Park Dr in 187 ft.
-
Turn left onto Mesker Park Dr in 0.7 mi.
- Turn right onto N St Joseph Ave 0.5 mi.
- Turn left onto W Franklin St. Your destination will be on the right in 0.2 mi.
CONNECT WITH US