black order delivery and pickup now button
Get Directions
Call Store

Page Park Cookie Plug –
cookie bakery in Fort Myers, FL

Pink, white, and black sign over a storefront that says 'Cookie Plug' with a black, white, and gray logo with a cookie and a plug attached to it. The windows have large pictures of cookies in the window in a box that says 'it was all a dream' in graffiti letters.
Digitally drawn white delivery truck with a cookie on it
Delivery
Digitally drawn dishes with pictures of large cookies with bites taken out of them
catering
Digitally drawn cookies on a carryout food bag
Carryout
cookie plug bakery loyalty rewards program white
Rewards
Digitally drawn white delivery truck with a cookie on it
Delivery
Digitally drawn cookies on a carryout food bag
Carryout
Digitally drawn dishes with pictures of large cookies with bites taken out of them
catering
cookie plug bakery loyalty rewards program white
Rewards
Pink, white, and black sign over a storefront that says 'Cookie Plug' with a black, white, and gray logo with a cookie and a plug attached to it. The windows have large pictures of cookies in the window in a box that says 'it was all a dream' in graffiti letters.

Bakery Hours for Cookies in Fort Myers:

Monday: 11am – 10pm
Tuesday: 11am – 10pm
Wednesday: 11am – 10pm
Thursday: 11am – 10pm
Friday: 11am – 11pm
Saturday: 11am – 11pm
Sunday: 1pm – 9pm

The Page Park Cookie Plug bakery in Fort Myers, FL, is next to Ray’s Barber Shop and Jersey Mike’s Subs. Pop into one of the best dessert restaurants in Fort Myers for some thicc cookie stacks, ice cream, and unique cookie cakes!

Why People Love Our Cookies in Fort Myers

Check out our reviews here!

Mint green circle with a white D with five golden stars

AARON SLACK

Some of the best store cookies I’ve ever had. All excellent. Very cookie dough like without being too raw. If you like your cookies on the doughy side, you will love these. They also have keto cookies, although we haven’t tried those yet. We will be back.

Blue circle with a white A with five golden stars

PATRICE COSCIA

We googled this, please. I’m gonna say that I was absolutely wowed by the quality of the cookie. This isn’t fake premade garbage it taste like absolute fresh real cookies. My first time here amazing experience.

Hot pink circle with a white B with five golden stars

BRANDY D

We got a new cookie joint in the hood & they are pretty delicious! The Cookie Plug opened yesterday! The staff was friendly but little shy. They definitely got thiccc cookies. Warm them up and on you go. The place is cool with graffiti art all over the walls.

Image of Google Maps that marks the Fort Myers Cookie Plug in FL

Get to the best cookies in Fort Myers from Hwy 41 S –

Follow these directions to get to our bakery:

  • Head east toward Cleveland Ave/US Hwy 41 S.

  • In 2.5 mi, turn right onto Cleveland Ave/US Hwy 41 S

  • In 466 ft, turn left onto Sunrise Blvd.

  • In 279 fr, Turn left onto Austin St.
  • Turn left onto Aldridge Ave
  • Turn left. Your destination will be on the left. 

Craving cookies in Fort Myers? Browse our menu.

CONNECT WITH US