Chatham-Arch Cookie Plug –
Indianapolis’ Top Bakery & Dessert Shop
Bakery Hours for Cookies in Indianapolis:
Monday: 2pm – 10pm
Tuesday: 2pm – 10pm
Wednesday: 2pm – 10pm
Thursday: 2pm – 10pm
Friday: 2pm – 2am
Saturday: 2pm – 2am
Sunday: 2pm – 10pm
Indianapolis’ top bakery & dessert shop, Cookie Plug, slangs fat, thick cookies—part cake, part brownie, part cookie—that redefine desserts in Indianapolis. We’re located across the street from Liberty Street and Century 21 Sheetz – Downtown. Our cookie shop vibe offers delivery, pickup, cookie ice cream sandwiches, custom cookie cakes, and more!
Why People Love Our Cookies in Indianapolis
Heather Bowers
This was such an amazing find. My husband and I were really craving something sweet and we just happened to stumble upon Cookie Plug. The cookies are huge and delicious. A must try.
Xerxes Adam
Door dashed this place tonight, but I was not disappointed!! We got the 4 cookie 2 purple drank combo, which was an awesome deal for the price. The cookies are crunchy on the outside, soft and gooey on the inside.
Lauren Taylor
This is my second time here at Cookie Plug! Let me tell you, the cookies beat Crumbl!! I love the vibe of this place! The owner and her Daughter Jackie are awesome, just from the kindness and energy they give.
Get to the best cookies in Indianapolis from the Indianapolis Zoo:
-
Head west toward W Washington St for 75 ft.
- Continue straight for 572 feet.
- Turn right in 0.2 mi.
-
Use the left 2 lanes to turn left onto W Washington St in 0.7 mi.
- Continue onto W Maryland St in 0.1 mi.
- Use the left 2 lanes to turn left onto S West St in 0.4 mi.
- Turn right onto W New York St in 1.o mi.
- Follow N Park Ave to your destination. Your destination will be on the left.
CONNECT WITH US